Showing posts with label Justice. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Justice. Show all posts

Saturday, May 9, 2020

Court ordered approval of "warm mix asphalt plant" to site plan

On April 20, 2020 the Superior Court of Litchfield County ordered, "...the PZ to issue an approval of the 2018 site plan application "..to "add a warm mix asphalt plant.." on the B. Metcalf Asphalt site in the Village of East Canaan in the town of North Canaan. Read full court decision HERE.

This court approved site plan for the asphalt plant...the Judge ruled that after 65 days Metcalf gets an automatic approval because the wording included in the 2016 special permit allowed a heated dryer for the aggregate to make the cold patch and that is the same as a Warm Asphalt Plant. It is not the same but at the hearing, no one explained that to the Judge. No one explained that the proposed Warm Asphalt Plant is sited adjacent to residences and 1⁄3 of a mile from the Blackberry River which is in itself against statutes in CT.

The effort to stop this from being permitted by the state of Connecticut now begins.

The truth of the Metcalf asphalt debacle is simple

The original ZEO appears to have done no research into the uses at the Mulville property before encouraging the Planning and Zoning to approve a special permit for Cold Patch processing. It seemed to be a business friendly decision with a seemingly sincere B.Metcalf who reassured the Commission and the neighbors that cold patch was all he intended to do.

Two years later B, Metcalf showed up at a Planning and Zoning Meeting with a lawyer and plans for a 4 million dollar Warm Asphalt Plant. The Planning and Zoning Commission not only had no lawyer at the meeting but the town attorney was retiring and no new attorney had been hired.

When the Planning and Zoning Commission handed back the application at that meeting because they thought that was the correct thing to do, there was no town attorney to advise them to actually vote on the application. Evidently no one except Metcalf’s Attorney knew about a rule that says you have to make a decision on the application before 65 days go by. Metcalf had already filed his 1st of 3 lawsuits against the town so everyone thought it was a waiting game. The neighbors tried to become intervenors in the lawsuits twice and were denied twice.

Two years later in April of 2020 the Judge ruled that after 65 days Metcalf gets an automatic approval because the wording included in the 2016 special permit allowed a heated dryer for the aggregate to make the cold patch and that is the same as a Warm Asphalt Plant. It is not the same but at the hearing, no one explained that to the Judge. No one explained that the proposed Warm Asphalt Plant is sited adjacent to residences and 1⁄3 of a mile from the Blackberry River which is in itself against statutes in CT.

“The law is simply human will written down. The law must let every acre of living earth be turned into tarmac, if such is the desire of people. Soon we'll know if we were right or wrong”
       - Richard Powers from the Overstory

Since the town didn’t stop this, how can the state allow it to go forward?

An asphalt plant does not belong on a used up gravel mine above the recharging area for the Aquifer that feeds all our wells.

It does not belong here.

---

What does this now approved asphalt plant site mean to the Town of North Canaan?


Here's how you can help...

Please copy and paste the below letter (add your own words if you prefer) into your email program and email to the following:


Justin Kronholm is our contact at the Attorney General Office for the State of Connecticut
EMAIL:  justin.kronholm@ct.gov
Telephone: 860-808-5191

Maria Horn
Legislative Office Building, Room 4000
Hartford, CT  06106-1591
1-800-842-8267
860-240-8585
EMAIL: maria.horn@cga.ct.gov

Jahana Hayes
U.S. House of Representatives
108 Bank Street, 2nd Floor
Waterbury, CT  06702
860-223-8412
EMAIL:  go to https://hayes.house.gov/contact/email-me

Craig Miner
Legislative Office Building
Room 3400
Hartford, CT  06106
800-842-1421
EMAIL:  https://ctsenaterepublican.com/contact-miner/

Richard Blumenthal – only via email
860-258-6940
Fax 860 258-6958
TO EMAIL:  http://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/contact
You will be asked to select an issue – choose Environment

---(copy letter below)---

Dear _________________

I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the potential construction of an asphalt plant in my town of North Canaan, CT.

The Litchfield Superior Court recently ordered the North Canaan Zoning Board to approve the site modification plan for B. Metcalf Paving, Inc. that includes the construction of a “warm” asphalt plant. The location of this site is within 1/3 of a mile of the Blackberry River (stocked with fish by the CT Department of Fisheries), the Beckley Furnace State Park and multiple personal residences. This seems to be in violation of CT DEEP regulations for clean air. The site is also on top of a potential water aquifer and a water course that supplies well water to many surrounding homes.

The judge’s decision relates strictly to a local zoning issue. He did not have any environmental evidence to consider as a group of residents were denied the right to intervene in the case to bring into consideration the detrimental effects that asphalt plants have on the health and well-being of those within the radius of any asphalt plant.

We ask for your help to investigate this and help the citizens of North Canaan maintain a safe and healthy quality of life.

Thank you for your consideration to this request.

Respectfully submitted,

YOUR NAME
ADDRESS
TELEPHONE
EMAIL

---(end letter)---


To be noticed we must speak out - together.


You are encouraged to file a complaint with the Attorney General regarding this issue at https://portal.ct.gov/AG/Common/Complaint-Form-Landing-page - Thank you.


You will need these details when you file your complaint:

Who is your complaint against?

  • Name Of Business Entity Or Provider Of Services: B. METCALF ASPHALT PAVING, INC, Et Al
  • Complainee First Name: Benjamin
  • Complainee Last Name: Metcalf
  • Street Address: 235 East Canaan Road
  • City/Town: North Canaan
  • State: CT
  • Zip Code: 06018
  • Phone Number:  (860) 435-1205
  • Email Address: bmetcalfasphalt@sbcglobal.net
  • Buisness Website: https://www.bmetcalfasphalt.com/

North Canaan, Connecticut contacts to email your displeasure to as well are:

Planning & Zoning - zoning@northcanaan.org
Charles P. Perotti - selectman@northcanaan.org
Craig Whiting (Selectmen) - cwhiting57@yahoo.com
Christian P. Allyn (Selectmen) - christianallyn@gmail.com
Inland Wetlands - c/o selectman@northcanaan.org


Ask to get on our email list. Thanks!


with your Social Media network. Thank you!
   



Tuesday, January 14, 2020

North Canaan Asphalt Plant awaiting judge's decision in Metcalf case

January 2, 2020 from The Lakeville Journal:

Court to rule. (click to enlarge for easy reading)
Please keep the pressure on!

Read about court case here.

Please voice your objection via email!

State of Connecticut Contacts:

State Representative Maria Horn - Maria.Horn@cga.ct.gov
U.S. House Representative Hayes -https://hayes.house.gov/contact/email-me
State Senator Craig Miner -https://ctsenaterepublicans.com/contact-miner/
U.S. Senator Blumenthal -https://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/contact/
U.S. Senator Murphy - https://www.murphy.senate.gov/contact
DEEP: deep.aquiferprotection@ct.gov

Town Official Contacts:

Planning & Zoning - zoning@northcanaan.org
Charles P. Perotti - selectman@northcanaan.org
Craig Whiting (Selectmen) - cwhiting57@yahoo.com
Christian P. Allyn (Selectmen) - christianallyn@gmail.com
Inland Wetlands - c/o selectman@northcanaan.org


with your Social Media network. Thank you!
   

Thursday, December 5, 2019

SPECIAL NOTICE Court Date Change

Court date changed...

Click to enlarge and read this Letter to the Editor.

Citizens of North Canaan:

On December 3, 2019 DECEMBER 11, 2019 the court will hear arguments regarding the (writ of) * mandamus filed by B. Metcalf Asphalt Paving, Inc against the Town of North Canaan. The writ requests that the court order the approval of the Site Plan Modification for Metcalf to build a Warm-Mix Asphalt Plant in North Canaan that the town returned without action. The court will hear arguments from both sides.

If you are available to attend this hearing in support of the Town in objection to this court ordered approval to site an asphalt plant in North Canaan it could be a powerful statement to the court. But please, if you attend, no demonstrative exhibits like signs and props for they would not be appropriate in the courtroom.

Location: LITCHFIELD JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURTHOUSE AT TORRINGTON
50 Field St, Torrington, CT 06790
Date: December 3, 2019
Time: 11 a.m.

Thank you.

* A (writ of) mandamus is an order from a court to an inferior government official ordering the government official to properly fulfill their official duties or correct an abuse of discretion.

Please voice your objection via email!

State of Connecticut Contacts:

State Representative Maria Horn - Maria.Horn@cga.ct.gov
U.S. House Representative Hayes -https://hayes.house.gov/contact/email-me
State Senator Craig Miner -https://ctsenaterepublicans.com/contact-miner/
U.S. Senator Blumenthal -https://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/contact/
U.S. Senator Murphy - https://www.murphy.senate.gov/contact
DEEP: deep.aquiferprotection@ct.gov

Town Official Contacts:

Planning & Zoning - zoning@northcanaan.org
Charles P. Perotti - selectman@northcanaan.org
Craig Whiting (Selectmen) - cwhiting57@yahoo.com
Christian P. Allyn (Selectmen) - christianallyn@gmail.com
Inland Wetlands - c/o selectman@northcanaan.org


with your Social Media network. Thank you!
   

Wednesday, November 27, 2019

Metcalf Asphalt Plant Environmental Injustice

A fight for environmental justice in North Canaan

Environmental injustice occurs when certain groups carry a greater share of environmental risks and hazards and lack the power to influence decisions about the environment. Ben Metcalf hopes the people of North Canaan lack the power to influence decisions which will have a significant impact on their environment and their homes. If he wins, he will have carried out environmental injustice.

Ben Metcalf is on his third lawsuit against our town. He is using a writ of mandamus to try to get a Judge to command our town to issue him a permit to build an asphalt plant. He is making a motion in limine to preclude any evidence at the trial. Evidence that should be presented in a town hearing for the townspeople of North Canaan to decide upon.

Ben Metcalf does not want our town to make its own decisions. He wants to be the only decision maker. He does not want to follow town and state regulations.

Being on the Stop the Asphalt Plant Committee (STAP) is different from serving on other boards or committees. We are fighting for our homes and the future of our town. According to the Blue Ridge Environmental Defense League, asphalt plants have negative effects on property values and health. One study documented property value losses of up to 56%, and another showed nearly half the residents had negative health effects. The EPA lists many chemicals involved in asphalt production as known carcinogens.

STAP is very grateful to the hundreds of citizens of North Canaan for showing up at meetings, signing petitions and even sending donations to cover legal fees and the cost of flyers. The public support is heartening.

Thank you,
Dolores Perotti

Please voice your objection via email!

State of Connecticut Contacts:

State Representative Maria Horn - Maria.Horn@cga.ct.gov
U.S. House Representative Hayes -https://hayes.house.gov/contact/email-me
State Senator Craig Miner -https://ctsenaterepublicans.com/contact-miner/
U.S. Senator Blumenthal -https://www.blumenthal.senate.gov/contact/
U.S. Senator Murphy - https://www.murphy.senate.gov/contact
DEEP: deep.aquiferprotection@ct.gov

Town Official Contacts:

Planning & Zoning - zoning@northcanaan.org
Charles P. Perotti - selectman@northcanaan.org
Craig Whiting (Selectmen) - cwhiting57@yahoo.com
Christian P. Allyn (Selectmen) - christianallyn@gmail.com
Inland Wetlands - c/o selectman@northcanaan.org


with your Social Media network. Thank you!